Monday, July 03, 2006

Upcoming topics...

There were many things to consider... many overtures that had us thinking about some tough stuff. Now that I've been home for over a week, it's time to start getting that stuff out on 'paper'. And you, my audience, will have to just deal with it. I hope that maybe someone will comment and let me know what you think.... and I really hope that at least one person will be inspired to think about these topics in a new, different or deeper way.

Upcoming topics will include:
  • The Trinity Paper
  • The Theological Task Force on Peace, Unity, and Purity in the Church
  • Divestment
  • Presbyterian Men
  • Joan Grey
  • Fellow TSADS
  • The experience
Overall it was an experience not to be missed. Really, every Presbyterian should be participating in the GA experience at least once in their lives. What a great perspective on our church as a larger body... and a great opportunity to witness the power of the Holy Spirit at work in God's church. I would do it again... and I hope to be involved in new and exciting ways in the future.

Photo website

I've posted my pics on my photo website:
http://community.webshots.com/user/arielpsu

Enjoy!

Friday, June 30, 2006

Day 8 - Thursday

And the last day... mostly just cleaning up the last bits of business.

~~~~~~~~~
  • Thursday, 22 June 2006: 8:30 – 11:30am (Plenary)
    • Worship
    • Prayer
    • Moderator’s Pastoral Message
      • Avoid gossip
        • “I heard that…”
      • Avoid slander
        • Do not attribute/assume motives – ASK
      • Tell people “Don’t believe everything you see or hear in the media.”
      • Challenging week – if you have hurt or been hurt, address it here and now before we leave
    • Deborah Block – Sunday’s lectionary Psalm 133
      • Birmingham Pledge
        • City of B’ham offers visitors
    • Motion to put sermon and prayer texts on Website – so ordered
    • 02 Bills and Overtures
      • Minutes from Wednesday until dinner are in order
      • Rest of minutes will be approved later
    • 03 General Assembly Procedures

Yr

Approved

per capita
cents increase

yet to be approved

per capita
cents increase

2006

$36,705

1.55

--

--

2007

$188,900

8.22

--

--

2008

$107,417

4.86

--

--

      • GAC will make adjustments for 2006 since the rate cannot be changed at this time
      • Move to approve revised 2007-8 Per Capita
        • 2007 Expenditure $12,473,683 à $12,662,583
        • 2008 Expenditure $14,954,257 à $15,061,674
        • Motion to consider sending all reports electronically instead of by mail
          • 81, 19, 0
        • Increase between 2007 and 2008 mostly due to next GA with additional delegates
        • Passes
      • Move to approve revised per capita rate for 2007-8
        • $5.72 à 5.79
        • 92, 7, 1
      • Report on approved commissioner vouchers
        • $194,374.45 plus additional vouchers
    • 08 Mission Coordination

Yr

Approved

yet to be approved

2006

$8,384

--

2007

$46,918

--

2008

$36,534

--

      • Move to amend 08-13.
        • “…and Program in the total amount of $96,298,454[,and direct the General Assembly Council to make the adjustments necessary to incorporate into these budgets the items with financial implications that have been approves by the 17th General Assembly (2006).] – So ordered

    • YAD gifts
      • Silly song
      • Cards of encouragement for Joan
      • Stoles of rope with carabeeners for Moderator, Vice-Moderator, Stated Clerk
    • Rick Ufford-Chase – moment of Personal Privilege
      • 11-01 “217th GA does not believe that the PCUSA should tell a sovereign nation…”
        • Would like to change to “The 217th General Assembly believes that the PC(USA) should use the greatest possible care in speaking to or with a sovereign nation on any matter including how to handle protecting its borders or matters of national defense”
      • Motion to reconsider 11-01
        • Discussion
        • 46, 53, 1
    • Commendation to GA for care taken with budgetary concerns
    • General Assembly Council & Committee on the Office of the General Assembly
      • Allison S – new GAC chair
      • Charles Easley – new GAC vice-chair
      • Cathy Ulrich – new COGA moderator
    • YAD from COGA to thanks S&L
    • OGA thanks to COLA
      • Commemorative plate
    • Thanks to Staff
    • COLA for San José
      • Downtown San José
    • Announcements
      • $711.15 for Malaria Relief
      • $2116.51 for Hunger Relief
      • Transportation and Luggage
      • LES info will remain there so we can refer to it
      • GA News is now available
    • Personal Word from Stated Clerk Clifton Kirkpatrick
    • Move to thank Mod and V-Mod

Fuller Luncheon Comments

Ron asked me to speak about my experience as a TSAD. Here is my "talk"...

~~~~~~~~~~~

I had no idea what I was getting into…

Ron stopped me outside my office at school and asked in passing “Would you be interested in attending GA in June? As Fuller’s representative?” Now, I have to be honest with y’all – I had no idea what that meant. I didn’t know TSADs existed (I’d only ever heard of YADs), I didn’t expect that Fuller would be invited to send someone, and I certainly never expected that I would be the ‘someone’ Fuller would select.

I stumbled over my answer to Ron – surprise and confusion causing my normal verbosity to go flying out the window! I told him I’d think and pray about it. And then he and I didn’t’ speak about it again for quite awhile… until it was almost too late! My application was quite late by the time we managed to get it in, but it was eventually accepted. My confirmation didn’t come through until May 5! Just over a month to read everything… including the PUP report!

I had no idea what I was getting into…

As I started to learn what my role and responsibilities were, I felt the weight of the responsibility, as well as the honor. Reading my committee materials during the last 3 weeks of the quarter, I found that I had no idea what these documents were trying to say! I could sense that there was a history here, and that most overtures were in response to something – but, again, I didn’t know what the ‘something’ was. And so I prayed and read and wrote and prayed some more… trusting that this was God’s calling on me for this time and that God would provide me with the knowledge and strength for this.


I had no idea what I was getting into…

Upon arrival in Birmingham, it began to occur to me that this was going to be a long week! The schedule provided to TSADs was long and full. The orientation dinner was full of more information and instruction than I was ready for. Having never been to a GA, I didn’t really know what to expect, or what would be helpful to know or ask. I sat and listened intently, hoping that I would remember the important things!

Once in committee, I was overjoyed. We had a diverse and powerful group. There were people I knew of: Katherine Doob Sakenfield, Mark Brewer, my fellow TSAD Aaron. The vice-moderator had called me in the weeks prior to arriving here, and I felt that I was meeting a friend. There were other interesting points of connection to draw us together as a single team – ready to do the work committed to us.

What an honor and privilege it was to have not just a voice but a vote on committee. I enjoyed the process of wrestling through these overtures together, thoughtfully seeking God’s will at each step of the way. It became a safe place for me to ask my silly parliamentary questions – without fear of laughter! I had no idea how a substitution motion worked – and the committee was great about explaining it! Heck, I even got the chance to make an amendment that passed – and I have the yellow piece of paper to prove it!

I had no idea what I was getting into…

Starting with the election of our new Moderator and moving right through to the discussion of the PUP report and the Church Orders overtures last night, plenary has been a varied experience for me. I don’t want to focus on the negative aspects, except to acknowledge that my experience has not been all sunshine and roses. I am often scolded for being a bit of a Polyanna – and so, want to make it clear that I certainly have some… constructive criticism – for the OGA regarding the role and treatment of TSADs, MADs, and EADs. We, as a whole, have felt a bit like the marginalized in this assembly. But none with whom I have spoken have had a totally negative experience. None would walk away saying that they wish they had not been here.

I am so glad that I have had this opportunity. To witness the decorum and love that was exhibited on the floor these past few days. To experience the passion and frustration in person. To feel, really feel, the presence of the Holy Spirit enter into this place as we earnestly sought God’s guidance and will. I will never forget the moment when, with tears silently rolling down my cheeks, the assembly sang together:

Spirit of the Living God fall afresh on me
Spirit of the Living God fall afresh on me
Melt me, mold me, fill me, use me
Spirit of the Living God fall afresh on me


I had no idea what I was getting into…

I have no idea what is next either. I will go back to school and try to help people talk about GA and PUP and divestment and hymnals… with intelligence. I pray that God can use me as a voice of moderation and middle ground as the extremes seek to understand each other. I pray that I can become the pastor that God calls me to be, serving the Church at whatever level and in whatever capacity I can.

I am grateful that God brought me here to learn and grow… and I look forward to being more involved in the future. I had no idea what I was getting into… but… no, make that and, I am excited that I accepted the offer. God had every idea of what He was getting me into… :)

Day 7 - Wednesday

It's taken awhile... but here they are. Notes from Wednesday, our longest day. We ended up working until 12.30am!!! But... we got everything done.

~~~~~~~~~
  • Wednesday, 21 June 2006: 7:00am – 8:30am (Small Church Breakfast)
    • Didn’t get much out of this experience… but it was ok.
    • The woman who sat next to me was a reporter. And she was TERRIBLE!! She dominated the conversation at the table, not allowing time for others to share and connect. And then… THEN… during the talk… she was “taking notes”. “Taking notes” that were obviously inaccurate (I was watching) and then working on a course evaluation for her DMin class. DURING THE TALK!! I was appalled. No wonder reporting is so bad. No wonder people are mis-quoted all the time!! She didn’t record the talk at all, just typed when she thought it sounded good. Very distracting to me… and highly inaccurate.
  • Wednesday, 21 June 2006: 10:30am – 12:00pm (Plenary)
    • Lift High the Cross
    • Our Story
    • Prayer – Doodle and Tres
    • Speak out
    • Bills and Overtures – Vice-Moderator
      • After GA Procedures FI
      • Church Orders
      • Mission Coord FI & Committee
      • Polity
      • Peacemaking
      • GA Procedures
      • Health
      • Social Justice
      • Move to change speaking time from 2 min to 90 sec
        • So moved
    • 03 GA Procedures FI report
      • Unchanged from yesterday

Yr

Approved

per capita
cents increase

yet to be approved

per capita
cents increase

2006

$8,565

0.36

$28,140

1.19

2007

$0

0

$198,680

8.65

2008

$8,565

0.039

$98,852

4.47

    • 04 Church Orders
      • 04-02 – On Confirming the requirements in G-6.0106b
        • Minority Report – Robert Gagnon
          • Original report as amended in Minority Report
        • Majority speaks
          • Do not need anything new to be said about this, since it’s clear already
        • Minority speaks
          • Confirms what is in
        • Main motion declared perfected without amendment
        • Minority report declared perfected without additional amendment
        • Debate – Shall the Substitute become the main?
          • For
            • Needing something clear to say to congregations
          • Against
            • Wanting to honor Res 5/6 from PUP – no more AI
        • Shall the Minority Report become the Main?
          • 33, 66, 1
        • 69, 30, 1
      • Motion (by Rob Mueller) to handle remaining 04 (03, 06, 08, 09, 10) that deal with G-6.0106b be considered addressed by 06-01 (and 04-01, 04-02)
        • Committee would like to take out 04 – done
          • Will address separately
        • 89, 11, 1
      • Motion (by Rob Mueller) to handle 04-04 that deals with G-6.0106b be considered addressed by 06-01 (and 04-01, 04-02)
        • 72, 27, 1
      • 04-05 On Commending Study of the Definitive Guidance of 1978
        • Move to approve as amended
        • 58, 42, 1
      • 04-07
        • Move to answer by action taken on 04-01
        • So ordered
    • Memorial Minute for Former Stated Clerk Rev. Dr. James E. Andrews
  • Wednesday, 21 June 2006: 12:00 – 1:45pm (Fuller Lunch)
    • Intro by Ron
    • My talk – to be posted separately
    • Dr. Mouw spoke about the future for Fuller and the Fund-raising campaign
  • Wednesday, 21 June 2006: 1:45pm – 5:30pm(Plenary)
    • Prayer
    • Choir
    • Speak Out
      • TSADs stood united and spoke:
        • The Theological Student Advisory Delegates gathered around this mic represent a diversity of theological views. In light of the decisions made thus far by this assembly, we, who represent our theological institutions, covenant to worship, study and pray with our fellow classmates that we might earnestly step forth as leaders, as the church enters this season of discernment.

          We have a vision of unity. We will strive, through our various ministries, to be faithful to Scripture and to work to rediscover our theological identity and to encourage those we shepherd to do the same. We are committed to promoting peace and Christian love within our denomination. We seek to serve with energy, intelligence, imagination, and love as we work to walk a path that leads us to peace, unity and purity.

          We want to be faithful to our calling and to trust in God alone. We stand united, even in diversity, and call to the church to do the same.
    • Motion to reconsider action to 04-05 On Commending Study of the Definitive Guidance of 1978
      • 20, 79, 1 – Motion fails
    • 02 Bills and Overtures
      • Minutes from 06/19-20 are in order

    • 08 Mission Coordination FI report

Yr

Approved

yet to be approved

2006

$8,384

$0

2007

$16,768

$30,150

2008

$16,384

$20,150

      • 08-01 Clarifying the Practice of Our Theology of Call…
        • Move to approve
        • So ordered
      • 08-02 Study Personnel policies
        • Move to disapprove
        • So ordered
      • 08-04 Limiting staff at GA Committee meetings
        • Move to disapprove
        • So ordered
      • 08-05 Termination benefits
        • Move to disapprove with comment
          • Already being addressed by GAC
      • CR 08-18 Instruct Women’s Ministries
        • Move to disapprove
        • So ordered
      • 08-13 Mission Budget
        • Move to approve in entirety
        • So ordered
      • 08-10 Administrative surcharge
        • Move to answer with:
        • 89, 10, 1
      • 08-06 HIV/AIDS
        • Move to approve as amended
        • So ordered
      • 08-11 ACREC
        • Move to approve
        • So ordered
      • CR 08-17 Mission Meeting
        • Move to approve as amended
        • So ordered
      • 08-12 Women of Color Consultation
        • Move to approve as amended (2008 NOT 2010)
        • Motion passes
      • 08-03 Men
        • Move to disapprove
        • Motion passes
      • 08-07 Study of Women
        • Move to disapprove
        • So ordered
      • 08-A, B, C – no action necessary

    • 05 Church Polity
      • Move to Consent
        • 05-07, 05-11-1
        • Discussion
          • 05-28 removed from Consent agenda
          • 05-11-2 removed from Consent agenda
          • 05-11 in its entirety – amendment coming
          • 05-23
          • 05-22
          • 05-25
        • Motion passes
      • 05-05
        • Move to approve
        • So ordered
      • 05-07
        • Move an amendment – strike the comment
          • Passes
        • Vote on disapproval without comments
          • 76, 23, 1
      • 05-11
        • Rec 1 – moved and passed
        • Motion to amend 05-11
          • So moved
        • 05-11.2.a1, a2 – editorial amendments
          • So ordered
        • Move 05-11.3-5 to approve as a block, 6-8 to disapprove as a block
        • Approved
      • 05-22 Non-geographical Synod
        • Move to refer with recommendation
        • Both original and referral/recommendation have to do with ways to study the feasibility of creating a non-geographical synod for Korean Congregations. Larissa and Trey and Chris are all opposed to both parts… we need to not consider these. This creates the possibility of segregation.
        • 64, 35, 1
      • 05-23 Amending Book of Order
        • Move to disapprove
        • Amend to refer to the Form of Government Task Force
          • 46, 54, 1 – Referral fails
        • 78, 21, 1
      • Motion to limit debate to 60 seconds – needs 2/3 vote and is not debatable
        • 73, 26, 1
      • 05-25
        • Motion to approve
        • 83, 16, 1

      • 05-28
        • Move to approve
        • Move to amend
          • Delete the paragraph beginning with “Throughout the Book of Order…” through “…turns permitted practices and prohibited practices.”
          • Motion fails
        • 94, 5, 1
    • Announcements
      • Plan for healing in the church
        • Moderator’s prayer retreats
          • At PCUSA camps and conference centers
          • Prayer for healing of church
          • Empower mission
          • New and creative ways to be church
          • Plan for first one in early fall
    • 11 Peacemaking and International Issues
      • Consent Agenda
        • 16, 25, 26, 38, 28, 37, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33
      • 11-36
        • Move to approve
        • So ordered
      • 11-27
        • Move to approve as amended
        • So moved
      • 11-40
        • Move to approve as amended
        • So moved
      • 11-01
        • Move to approve alternate resolution
        • Motion to delete Recommendation #1 and replace it with:
          • We regret any reportage that has caused misunderstanding of the PCUSA’s Commitment to Peace and Justice in Palestine and Israel
          • Fails
        • Motion to amend
          • Fails
        • I was trying to ask a question that I never got to ask because of how the motions went. So… here is my question:
          • I am interested in the change in language of this new resolution. I would like to request a member of the committee or a resource person address the intention of the committee’s alternate recommendation regarding the divestment practices.
        • 94, 5, 0
      • 11-02 through 11-15, 11-17 to 24, 34, 35, 39, 41
        • Move to answer with action taken on 11-01
        • Passes

    • 03 General Assembly Procedures
      • Consent Agenda
        • 03-A, 03-B, 06, 10, 12, 14, 15, 18, 20, 21, 23
        • Removal requests
          • 10
          • 03-A
          • 03-B
        • Motion for remaining items
          • So ordered
      • 07 Letters of encouragement
        • Move approval
        • 32, 66, 2
      • 19 Election of Associate Stated Clerks
        • Move approval
        • So ordered
      • 08 AI re: per capita
        • Move to disapprove with comment
        • So ordered
      • 13 Per Capita
        • Move to approve
        • So ordered
      • 09 Change in standing rules
        • Move to disapprove
        • So ordered
      • 16 Amend standing rules RE: AD
        • Move to disapprove both
        • So ordered
      • 22 Invitation to Pittsburgh
        • Move to approve
        • So ordered
      • 24 On Financial Reporting of Actual Cost…
        • Move to disapprove
        • Move to refer to Mission Support Services Offices of the GAC and the OGA for further consideration and a recommendation for the 218th General Assembly (2008).
          • 49, 50, 1
        • 79, 20, 1
      • 17 Historical Foundation at Montreat
        • Move to approve as amended
          • Still closing PHS @ Montreat
          • Protecting collection
            • Columbia Seminary
            • Philadelphia PHS
          • Establishing new historical programs
        • 02 Bills and Overtures moves to arrest report
          • So moved

  • Wednesday, 21 June 2006: 8:15pm – 12:35am (Plenary)
    • Speakout
    • 03 General Assembly Procedures
      • 17 Historical Foundation at Montreat
        • Move to approve as amended
          • Still closing PHS @ Montreat
          • Protecting collection
            • Columbia Seminary
            • Philadelphia PHS
          • Establishing new historical programs
          • Move to substitute for item 2-5, rename items 5&6 as 7&8
            • 2. Transfer oversight and administration for The Historical Foundation of the Presbyterian and Reformed churches at Montreat, Inc. to a specific board of directors of fifteen persons. This board will be in covenant relationship with and accountable to the Department of History. The ministry of this Historical Foundation will thus be in accord with and governed by the requirement of the Book of Order in G-9.0406 with specific regard to the control of all records which the Stated Clerk is charged to preserve. Thus no dispersion of the collection should occur at this time.
            • 3. Direct The Friends of Montreat, Inc. and the board to create alternative means of funding that is responsive to the donor base and is separate from the current per capita income of the General Assembly.
            • 4. Direct the board to reduce the annual operating expenses of the ministry to a level not greater than its annual income. In addition, the board would be responsible for developing policies and procedures for the oversight of The Historical Foundation, Inc,. in a manner that is consistent with the constitution of the church and the standing rules of the General Assembly.
            • 5. Report the progress on items 3 and 4 to the 218th General Assembly.
            • Discussion
              • Financial Implications: OHS budget is ~ $500,000 (90% from per capita)
          • Shall the substitute become the main?
            • 41, 58, 1
        • Final Vote on Main motion: 69, 29, 1
      • 01-05, 11 PHS @ Montreat
        • Move to answer with action on 03-17
        • So ordered
      • 03-19 – oversight earlier
        • Recognize
      • 03-10 PHS @ Montreat
        • Move to approve
        • So ordered
      • 03-A, 03-B
        • Only informational

    • 10 Health Issues
      • Consent Agenda
        • 10-05, 10-07, 10-08, 10-09
        • Removals? None.
      • 10-06 Disabilities
        • Move to approve with amendments
        • Passes
      • 10-01 Late term abortion
        • Move to approve as amended
          • Move to amend:
            • At the beginning of 10-01 add language from the 2003 Statement on Post-Viability and Late-Term Abortion beginning at line 3 with “The church has a responsibility to provide public witness…” all the way through “For any choice, we are accountable to God, however even when we err, God offers to forgive us.” (ending on line 35)
            • 84, 15, 1
          • Further discussion
          • Move to delete “supersedes” that this statement might be added to previous Statements of General Assemblies.
            • This motion will put our previous motion in contradiction
            • 40, 58, 1
          • Move to add language to make clear the position on choice
            • Failed
          • 76, 23, 1
      • 10-02 Financial support for or against abortion
        • Move to disapprove
          • Move to amend and approve: delete “or against abortion” and add “pro-life or pro-choice issues”
            • Out of order because the motion is to disapprove. We would need to defeat the main motion before this motion to approve with amendment would be in order.
          • 85, 15, 0
      • 10-03 On standing clearly against the practice of abortion
        • Move to respond with alternate resolution
          • 84, 15, 1
      • 10-04 Monitoring Report
        • Move to approve as amended
          • By show of hands
          • So moved
    • 09 Social Justice Issues
      • Consent Agenda: 04, 05, 06, 07, 17, 22, 23
        • So moved
      • 09-16
        • Passes
      • 09-09
        • Move to approve
        • So moved
      • 09-14 Task Force to Assess the Effects of Government FBI
        • Move to approve as amended
        • So moved

      • 09-03 Medical use of Marijuana
        • Move to approve
        • So moved
      • 09-15 Immigrants
        • Move to approve as amended
        • So ordered
      • Motion to consider 09-01, 08, 10,11, 12, 18, 19, 21, 24 as a package
        • Amend to Remove 10, 11, 01, 19
        • With Clifton Kirkpatrick’s help we stopped this incessant game and voted
          • 94, 5, 1
      • 09-12, 09-18
        • Move to answer with 09-15
          • Motion passes
      • Motion to recess until tomorrow morning
        • 19, 81, 0
      • 09-13 Irish adoptions
        • Move to disapprove
        • 94, 6, 0
      • 09-01 Petitions against torture
        • Move to approve
        • 66, 33, 1
      • 09-11 Human Rights
        • Move to approve as amended
          • Move to amend “/or combatants and” after “and all foreign governments, and”
          • 62, 36, 2
      • 09-20
        • Move to disapprove
          • Because of redundancy, not because we approve of suicide bombings
        • 38, 61, 1
        • Move to approve
          • Move to add “and terrorism” after each instance of “suicide bombing”
        • Again, I had a comment/question/position that didn’t get to be shared because the question was called before I could get to the microphone
          • Would the committee be amenable to disapproving the motion with comment? Since the committee feels we do not need to repeat a position that already exists elsewhere, could we not honor the committee and the commissioners’ intent by disapproving an overture that is unnecessary while still condemning the practice and affirming our precious stances on terrorism, human rights, and the like.
        • Approved

    • 09-10 Just Globalization
      • Move to approve
        • Motion to delete F, item #4
          • 82, 17, 1
        • Motion to change from approve to receive
          • 39. 61, 0
        • Motion to delete B.2.a
          • 28, 71, 1
        • 94, 5, 1 to call all previous questions
      • 78, 21, 1
    • 09-24 Originally Native “Return to Earth”
      • Move to approve
      • 89, 10, 1
    • 09-08 Usury for the 21st Century
      • Move to approve
      • 94, 5, 0
    • 09-02 Smithfield Packing
      • Move to approve with comment
      • Move to refer to ACSWP
        • Invitation from Smithfield to have conversation
        • 67, 31, 1
    • 09-21 Raising Minimum Wage
      • Move to approve as amended
      • So moved
    • 09-19 Coalition of Immokalee
      • Move to approve
      • So moved
    • Announcements
      • Worship here @ 8.30am
      • Meeting immediately following
      • Sets of GA Newspapers available outside
      • Come Thou Fount
      • Closing Prayer
  • Wednesday, 21 June 2006: 12:35 – 12:45am (Committee #08)
    • One motion, to permit GAC to adjust budget as needed, since the implications are minimal.
      • Passed unanimously

Friday, June 23, 2006

I'm alive...

My notes from the last days will be posted soon... for now I'm enjoying a few days of vacation before heading back to Pasadena. More updates on Monday... but I'm not going to be posting until then. I need the break.

Tuesday, June 20, 2006

Day 6 - Tuesday

Today's notes. It was a big day. You'll probably see this on the news - I'm not even wanting to watch, really. There is no way that the media will report this correctly... it'll be spun like a nice wad of cotton candy. Well... except not so sweet.

So... the PUP report. I know that my notes will not be sufficient... so let me say a few words. First of all, before you assume too much - please read it for yourself. It doesn't say what many people think it says!! There are no references to homosexuality; it doesn't talk about the ordination of homosexuals; it doesn't define marriage...

What the report does do is talk about the church remembering to be one! And remembering to seek God. And looking to Scripture. And the "controversial" part talks about Presbyteries having the power to approve people for ordination - something that they have had all along!! The Authoritative Interpretation in Recommendation #5 is where most people freak out and run screaming. This is where most people draw the line in the sand.

But what it says - simply and completely - is this:

5. The Task Force on Peace, Unity, and Purity of the Church recommends that the 217th General Assembly (2006) approve the following authoritative interpretation of section G-6.0108 of the Book of Order:

a. The Book of Confessions and the Form of Government of the Book of Order set forth the scriptural and constitutional standards for ordination and installation.

b. These standards are determined by the whole church, after the careful study of Scripture and theology, solely by the constitutional process of approval by the General Assembly with the approval of the presbyteries. These standards may be interpreted by the General Assembly and its Permanent Judicial Commission.

c. Ordaining and installing bodies, acting as corporate expressions of the church, have the responsibility to determine their membership by applying these standards to those elected to office. These determinations include:

(1) Whether a candidate being examined for ordination and/or installation as elder, deacon, or minister of Word and Sacrament has departed from scriptural and constitutional standards for fitness for office,

(2) Whether any departure constitutes a failure to adhere to the essentials of Reformed faith and polity under G-6.0108 of the Book of Order, thus barring the candidate from ordination and/or installation.

d. Whether the examination [assembly amendment: and ordination and installation decision] comply with the constitution of the PCUSA, and whether the ordaining/installing body has conducted its examination reasonably, responsibly, prayerfully, and deliberately in deciding to ordain a candidate for church office is subject to review by higher governing bodies.

e. All parties should endeavor to outdo one another in honoring one another’s decisions, according the presumption of wisdom to ordaining/installing bodies in examining candidates and to the General Assembly, with presbyteries’ approval, in setting standards.

Scripture informs our Constitution, the Church trusts the General Assembly and National governmental process to uphold the Constitution, the local church (Presbyteries and congregations) apply the standards found in the Constitution and Scripture (as affirmed by the national government), examine candidates, honor one another's decisions (but there are always ways to discuss/debate/question them). That's all. That's all it says. Take a deep breath and read before making assumptions about the future of the church.

Follow the example of the Task Force... and of the General Assembly... and
pray. Let God be the One to guide the Church. The Spirit was present and among us today as we worked on this. While I am convinced that no one is really happy with the outcome, I do think we are now in a position to have some discussion and work toward a more concrete answer for which many people are desperate.

~~~~~~~~~~
  • Tuesday, 20 June 2006: 9:00am – 12:00pm (Plenary)
    • Opening story – from Desert Fathers/Mothers
      • If you will, you can become all flame
    • Opening Prayer
    • Moderator CPC
      • Elected last night
    • Report from 03 – Financial Implications (Vince Thomas, Moderator)
      • Per capita budget

Yr

Approved

per capita
cents increase

yet to be approved

per capita
cents increase

2006

$8,565

0.36

$28,140

1.19

2007

$0

0

$198,680

8.65

2008

$8,565

0.039

$98,852

4.4

    • Report from 08 – Mission Budget Financial Implications
      • Mission budget

Yr

Approved

yet to be approved

2006

$8,384

$0

2007

$16,768

$30,150

2008

$16,384

$20,150

    • 08 Mission Coordination and Budget (Part I)
      • 08-15 – Confirmation of Linda Bryant Valentine
        • Nancy Kahaian
        • Linda Bryant Valentine
        • Move to approve
          • 87, 10, 3
        • Installation of Linda
        • Thanks to Search Committee and John Detterick
        • Party to meet and thank Linda and John
          • Tonight following evening plenary in Concert Hall lobby
        • Motion to thank John Detterick
          • So ordered
      • 08-08 – Change to the GAC Structure (as amended)
        • Motion passes
      • 08-09 – Changes to Manual of Operations (as amended)
        • So ordered
      • 08-14 – Changes to Organization for Mission
        • So ordered
      • 08-16 – Latitude for GANC
        • So ordered
    • GANC – Nominations for GAC
      • Only had to vote on individuals that were challenged.
    • Motion to have Speak Out now and start after lunch with 06
    • 1.30pm will begin with prayer – doors will be closed until prayer is completed
  • Tuesday, 20 June 2006: 1:30am – 5:30pm (Plenary)
    • Open with prayer
      • Image of approaching our home church, walking in, walking to the communion table, touching the top, running our fingers over the words “In Remembrance of Me” and then placing on the table the one thing…
      • Closed with “Spirit of the Living God, Fall Afresh on Me”
    • 06 Ecclesiology – Blair Monie, Minister Commissioner, Moderator
      • TTF
        • Rec 1-4
          • Most important
          • While we may be on diff theo pages – we are in one book: Christian Reformed Presbyterian
          • We are all right about one thing: Christ
          • How can we remain one body?
            • Form diverse Discernment groups in Presbyteries
            • Use tools for communal discernment – as a compliment, not replacement, for parliamentary procedures
      • Committee Comment
        • One central goal – all meetings/deliberations
          • Fairness, impartial leadership
          • Access to every voice
          • Listen to each voice
        • Listened:
          • 60 people in Open Hearings
          • 22 Overture Advocates
        • Spent time in worship and discernment
        • Prayed for guidance during deliberations
      • 06-01 – Adopt the Task Force
        • Motion to accept Rec 1-4 as amended
          • 91, 8, 1
        • Motion to adopt with comment Rec 5 (as amended), Rec 6 and Rec 7 as one indivisible package
          • Minority Report – Disapprove 5, Approve 6 & 7
          • Speech in affirmation of Pt 5 from platform
          • Speech in affirmation of Minority Report
          • Perfect the Main Motion – Accept 5 (as amended), 6 and 7
            • Move to amend by striking the word “Authoritative”
              • AD – no
              • C – 19, 80, 1
            • Question to TTF – impact of removing Rec 5 from the report
              • Stacy Johnson – TTF
                • Intent to be a single package
                • Not appropriate to amend constitution, but to make it clear
                • Failure to pass 5 will lead to a theological viewpoint (already passed in Rec 1) but without practical ‘legs’
              • ??
                • AI changes practice without consulting entire church – will lead to division in the church
            • How does TTF feel about committee amendment to 5
              • Minority side
                • Support the amendment
              • Mike Lauten – TTF
                • “We like it, we wish we had thought of it”
            • Move to amend
              • Insert after first appearance of word “examination” the words “and ordination and installation decision”; change the word “complies” to “comply”
              • 58, 41, 1
            • Declared perfected
          • Perfect the Minority Report
            • Question – Rec 6 is dependent on 5
            • No move to strike 6!
            • Declared perfected – even with the inconsistency!!
          • Discussion
            • So far is it going fairly well – passionate while remaining faithful. I, personally, am thoroughly confused and unsure how I want to vote. I want to honor the work of the TTF and keep the recommendations in tact… but I don’t know if I want to open the door to the liberal interpretations that may be coming. But I don’t see that the intent of Rec 5 would be to allow such interpretations… I just don’t see it!
            • 45, 55, 0 – Main motion remains the main motion
          • Move to recommend 217th GA refer w/ comment # 5, 6 to Presbyteries with following work
            • From committee
              • Presbyteries have already had 9 months to consider and respond – including overtures to this GA
            • 45, 55, 0 – Motion fails
          • Final Vote
            • AD
              • YADs: Y
              • TSADs: Y – 64, 36, 0
              • MADs: Y
              • EADs: Y
            • C: 57, 43, 0 – Motion Passes
          • Prayer – ended with Kum-ba-yah J
      • 06-05 Rec 3
        • Passes
      • 06-07 with comment
        • So ordered
      • 06-11 disapproval
        • So ordered
      • All remaining items by action taken on 06-01
        • So ordered
    • Patrick Wrisley – Questions
      • Do we know what we have done?
      • Will the GA Office realize the need that it will have to, more than likely, work with fellow churches and Presbyteries that are having difficult reactions to the actions taken today?
      • Does the GA Office have a TF or group that will look at the consequences of people withholding funds?
      • Clerks response
        • A letter will be prepared to go to churches
    • 04 Church Orders
      • 04-11 – Christian Marriage
        • Move to disapprove
        • W-4.9001 – already clear about marriage
        • Motion passes
      • 04-12 Reaffirming that Marriage Between a man and a woman…
        • Move to disapprove
        • 65, 33, 2 – Motion to disapprove carries
      • Move to reconsider 04-11
        • Because we didn’t understand the voting
        • 60, 40, 0
      • 04-11
        • 65, 34, 0
      • Move to reconsider 04-12
        • Because we didn’t understand the voting
        • 247, 247, 0 – Motion fails J
      • 04-13 On Pastoral Counsel for Sexual Sin
        • Move to disapprove
        • 66, 34, 0
      • 04-01 New AI
        • Move to disapprove
        • Passing the PUP report
        • Motion to refer with all concurrences motion to 218th GA
          • Fails
        • 81, 18, 1
    • Close for the night. The rest will be addressed tomorrow